What Are We Really Arguing About When We Argue About Israel?

by
Abi Dauber Sterne

In many Jewish families today, two very different conversations are taking place.

In the United States, some parents are struggling with children who have become increasingly distanced from Israel, even anti-Zionist. For many parents, this feels like a rejection not only of Israel, but of deeply held family values and the hard-won achievements and sacrifices of generations of Jews who fought for Jewish agency.

In Israel, some of us are struggling with what seems like the opposite argument. Our teenage and adult children have lived through years of violence, fear, and war. And, seemingly as a result, many have come to believe that the only way to keep Jews safe is to live in a country without Arabs. Some deny that this is racism; others say, without irony, “Better to be racist than dead.”

These are certainly not equivalent positions. But the difficulty of speaking with those who hold opposing views cannot be underestimated. For parents and children alike, there is increasingly a feeling of alienation at best, and betrayal at worst. How can someone we love not share our values?

In recent weeks, as I've traveled between Israel and the United States, I've noticed another difference in the conversations taking place. In Israel, there have been many calls for a “unity” government, bringing together Jewish political parties across a limited spectrum that does not include the far right or Arab parties. Those calling for this believe that, in order for Jews to survive, we must have exclusive control over our own security and political future.

In the United States, however, I've increasingly heard calls for Gadi Eisenkot, the leader of the Yashar party tasked by President Isaac Herzog to form the next Israeli government, to build a governing coalition that includes Arab parties. For those calling for this, Arab leadership in the Israeli government would be a clear demonstration of the values of equality and freedom for all its citizens.

These contrasting views, almost mirror images of one another, touch on a central question of modern Zionism: What does it mean to be a Jewish and democratic state?

As I think about how to make these arguments between us more productive and healthier, I remind myself that integrating Jewish and democratic values into the modern State of Israel has never been easy.

Rather than seeing these arguments as a zero-sum game, I try to remember that each “side” believes it is holding up core values of our Zionist tradition. And even when someone I'm speaking with is concerned with holding up a value that feels less central to me, I try to appreciate what they are trying to protect.

I find that it helps to return to the question: What does it mean to be a Jewish and democratic state? Rather than simply stating my own position and trying to convince the other person that I am right, I try to reframe the conversation around this shared question.

This isn’t because we will necessarily agree on the answer (we likely won’t), or because the tensions between these values can easily be resolved. But reminding ourselves that we are wrestling with the same fundamental question can change the nature of the conversation.

Instead of arguing over who is right and who has betrayed our values, we can begin to explore what those values mean, what we are each afraid of losing, and what kind of Jewish state we are trying to build.

Does Israel fit?

A new argument story by Abi Dauber Sterne & Robbie Gringras

An Israeli rabbi and American publisher clash over a book on Jewish holidays when one chapter—Yom Ha'atzmaut—becomes a sticking point, raising deeper questions about Israel's place in Jewish life today.

Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.

Related Articles

THOUGHTS for the sake of argument

A monthly newsletter featuring our latest research, reflections, and resources.

Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.